Disproportionate Share Hospital
The Medicare DSH adjustment provision under Section 1886(d) (5) (F) of the Act was enacted by section 9105 of the COBRA of 1985 and became effective for discharges occurring on or after 5/1/1986. According to section 1886(d) (5) (F) of the Act, there are two methods for a hospital to qualify for the Medicare DSH adjustment. The primary method is for a hospital to qualify based on a complex statutory formula that results in the DSH patient percentage. The DSH patient percentage is equal to the sum of the percentage of Medicare inpatient days attributable to patients eligible for both Medicare Part A and SSI, and the percentage of total inpatient days attributable to patients eligible for Medicaid by not Medicare Part A. The DSH patient’s percentage is defined as:
Medicare SSI Days / Total Medicare Days + Medicaid, Non-Medicare Days / Total Patient Days = DSH Patient Percent
The alternate special exception method is for large urban hospitals that can demonstrate that more than 30 percent of their total net inpatient care revenues come from state and local governments for indigent care (other than Medicare or Medicaid).
Under the primary method to qualify for DSH adjustments, the first computation includes the number of hospital patient days used by patients who, for those days, were entitled to both Medicare Part A and SSI (excluding state supplementation). This number is divided by the number of patient days used by patients under Medicare Part A for that same period. The second computation includes hospital patient days used by patients who, for those days, were eligible for medical assistance under a state plan approved under title XIX, but who were not entitled to Medicare Part A. This number is divided by the total number of hospital patient days for that same period.
Hospitals whose DSH patient percentage exceeds 15 percent are eligible for a DSH payment adjustment based on another statutory formula. The formula varies for urban hospitals with 100 or more beds and rural hospitals with 500 or more beds, hospital that qualify as rural referral centers or sole community hospitals, and other hospitals.
Table of Contents
- The Medicare Fraction (Medicare Proxy)
- The Medicaid Fraction (Medicaid Proxy)
- Medicaid (Title XIX) Defined
- Included Medicaid Days
- Included Title XIX Eligible Days
- Excluded Days
- Excluded State Program Days
- Other Excluded Days
- Qualifying for DSH Payments
The Medicare Fraction (Medicare Proxy)
The Medicare Fraction is computed by dividing the number of patient days that are furnished to patients who are entitled to both Medicare Part A and SSI benefits by the total number of patient days furnished to patients entitled to benefits under Medicare Part A. This percentage is supplied to providers by CMS and is determined on the federal fiscal year. If a hospital prefers, it may request that CMS calculate the Medicare fraction based upon their cost reporting period, rather than the federal fiscal year. Instructions for requesting this recalculation can be found at 42 CFR 412.106(b)(3).
The Medicaid Fraction (Medicaid Proxy)
The Medicaid Fraction is computed by dividing the number of patient days furnished to patients who, for those days, were eligible for Medicaid but were not entitled to benefits under Medicare Part A by the number of total hospital patient days in the same period. For purposes of counting patient days, as indicated in PRM 15-2 Section 3605.1 providers should report days in the cost reporting period in which the discharge is reported.
Section 3133 of the Affordable Care Act
Section 3133 of the Affordable Care Act amends the Medicare DSH adjustment provision under section 1886(d) (5) (F) of the Act and establishes 1886(r) which provides for an additional payment for a hospital’s uncompensated care. As proposed in the FY 2014 IPPS proposed rule, the regulations that implement this provision are in proposed subpart I of 42 CFR part Section 412.106. Changes to the Medicare DSH Payment: Effective for discharges occurring on or after FY 2014, hospitals will receive 25 percent of the amount they previously would have received under the current statutory formula for Medicare DSH.
Additional Payment for Uncompensated Care: The remainder, equal to 75 percent of what otherwise would have been paid as Medicare DSH will become available for an uncompensated care payments after the amount is reduced for changes in the percentage of individuals that are uninsured. Each Medicare DSH hospital will receive an uncompensated care payment based on its share of insured low-income days (that is, the sum of Medicaid days and Medicare SSI days) reported by Medicare DSH hospitals.
Each hospital’s uncompensated care payment is the product of three factors. These three factors are:
- 75 percent of the estimated DSH payments that would otherwise be made under the old DSH methodology (section (d)(5)(F) of the Social Security Act);
- 1 minus the percent change in the percent of individuals under the age of 65 who are uninsured (minus 0.1 percentage points for FY 2014, and minus 0.2 percentage points for FY 2015 through FY 2017); and
- A hospital’s amount of uncompensated care relative to the amount of uncompensated care for all DSH hospitals expressed as a percentage
Medicaid (Title XIX) Defined
Medicaid is a cooperative federal-state program that provides health care to indigent persons who are aged, blind, disabled or members of families with dependent children.
The Medicaid Program is jointly financed by the federal and state governments and administered by the states according to federal guidelines. Medicaid, under Title XIX of the Social Security Act, establishes two eligibility groups for medical assistance: categorically needy and medically needy.
Participating states are required to provide Medicaid coverage to the “categorically needy”. These persons are eligible for cash assistance under two federal programs: TANF which replaced the AFDC Program in 1996 and SSI.
Additionally, participating states may elect to provide for payment of medical services for “medically needy” individuals that are aged, blind or disabled. These individuals, whose incomes or resources, while exceeding the financial eligibility requirements for the categorically needy, are insufficient to pay for necessary medical care.
Included Medicaid Days
In calculating the number of Medicaid days, the hospital must determine whether the patient was eligible for Medicaid under a state plan approved under Title XIX on the day of service. If the patient was eligible, the day counts in the Medicare disproportionate share adjustment calculation. The statutory formula for “Medicaid days” reflects several key concepts. First, the focus is on the patient's eligibility for Medicaid benefits as determined by the state, not the hospital’s “eligibility” for some form of Medicaid payment.
Then the focus is on the patient’s eligibility for medical assistance under an approved Title XIX state plan, not the patient's eligibility for general assistance under a state-only program. Additionally, it should be emphasized that allowable medical assistance is limited to an approved Title XIX state plan, not medical assistance under a state-only program or other program. Thus, for a day to be counted, the patient must be eligible on that day for medical assistance benefits under the federal-state cooperative program known as Medicaid (under an approved Title XIX state plan).
In other words, for purposes of the Medicare disproportionate share adjustment calculation, the term “Medicaid days” refers to days on which the patient is eligible for medical assistance benefits under an approved Title XIX state plan. The term "Medicaid days" does not refer to all days that have some relation to the Medicaid program, through a matching payment or otherwise; if a patient is not eligible for medical assistance benefits under an approved Title XIX state plan, the patient day cannot become a “Medicaid day” simply by virtue of some other association with the Medicaid Program.
Effective for cost reports settled after 2/27/1997, Medicaid days, for purposes of the Medicare disproportionate share adjustment calculation, includes all days during which a patient is eligible, under a state plan approved under Title XIX, for Medicaid benefits, even if Medicaid did not make payment for any services. Thus, Medicaid days includes, but are not limited to, days that are determined to be medically necessary but for which payment is denied by Medicaid because the provider did not bill timely, days that are beyond the number of days for which a state will pay, days that are utilized by a Medicaid beneficiary prior to an admission approval but for which a valid enrollment is determined within the prescribed period, and days for which payment is made by a third party.
In addition, the calculation recognizes days that are utilized by a Medicaid beneficiary who is eligible for Medicaid under a state plan approved under Title XIX through a MCO or HMO.
However, in accordance with 42 CFR 412.106(b)(4) a day does not count in the Medicare disproportionate share adjustment calculation if the patient was entitled to both Medicare Part A and Medicaid on that day. Therefore, once the eligibility of the patient for Medicaid under a state plan approved under Title XIX has been verified, you must determine whether any of the days are dual entitlement days and, to the extent that they are, subtract them from the other days in the calculation.
Included Title XIX Eligible Days
Actual 1902(r)(2) and 1931(b) Days – Days for patients eligible under a state plan based on a 1902(r)(2) or 1931(b) election. These patients are Medicaid-eligible under the Title XIX state plan under the authority of these provisions, which is exercised by the state in the content of the approved state plan.
Medicaid Optional Targeted Low-Income Children (CHIP-related) Days – Days for patients who are Title XIX-eligible and who meet the definition of “optional targeted low income children” under section 1905(u)(2). The difference between these children and other Title XIX children is the enhanced FMAP rate available to the state. These children are fully Medicaid-eligible under the state plan.
1915(c) Eligible Patient (the “217” group) Days – Days for patients in the eligibility group under the state plan for individuals under a Home and Community Based Services waiver. This group includes individuals who would be Medicaid-eligible if they were in a medical institution. Under this special eligibility group, they are Medicaid-eligible under the state plan.
Retroactive Eligible Days – Days for patients not enrolled in the Medicaid Program at the time of service, but found retroactively eligible for Medicaid benefits for the days at issue. These patients are Medicaid-eligible under the state plan.
Medicaid Managed Care Organization Days – Days for patients who are eligible for Medicaid under a state plan when the payment to the hospital is made by an MCO for the service. An MCO is the financing mechanism for Medicaid benefits, and payment for the service through the MCO does not affect eligibility.
Excluded Days
Many states operate programs that include both state-only and federal-state eligibility groups in an integrated program. For example, some states provide medical assistance to beneficiaries of state-funded income support programs. These beneficiaries, however, are not eligible for Medicaid under a state plan approved under Title XIX, and, therefore, days utilized by these beneficiaries do not count in the Medicare disproportionate share adjustment calculation. If a hospital is unable to distinguish between Medicaid beneficiaries and other medical assistance beneficiaries, then it must contact the state for assistance in doing so.
In addition, if a given patient day affects the level of Medicaid DSH payments to the hospital but the patient is not eligible for Medicaid under a state plan approved under Title XIX on that day, the day is not included in the Medicare DSH calculation.
It should be noted that the types of days discussed above are not necessarily the only types of excluded days.
To provide consistency in both components of the calculation, any days that are added to the Medicaid day count must also be added to the total day count, to the extent that they have not been previously added.
Regardless of the type of allowable Medicaid day, the hospital bears the burden of proof and must verify with the state that the patient was eligible under one of the allowable categories during each day of the patient's stay. The hospital is responsible for and must provide adequate documentation to substantiate the number of Medicaid days claimed. Days for patients that cannot be verified by state records to have fallen within a period wherein the patient was eligible for Medicaid cannot be counted.
Excluded State Program Days
General Assistance Patient Days – Days for patients covered under a state-only (or county-only) general assistance program (whether or not any payment is available for health care services under the program). These patients are not Medicaid-eligible under the state plan.
Other State-Only Health Program Patient Days – Days for patients covered under a state-only health program. These patients are not Medicaid-eligible under the state plan.
Charity Care Patient Days – Days for patients not eligible for Medicaid or any other third-party payer, and claimed as uncompensated care by a hospital. These patients are not Medicaid-eligible under the state plan.
Separate CHIP Days – Days for patients who are eligible for benefits under a non-Medicaid state program furnishing child health assistance to targeted low-income children. These children are, by definition, not Medicaid-eligible under a state plan.
Medicaid DSH Days – Days for patients who are not eligible for Medicaid benefits, but are considered in the calculation of Medicaid DSH payments by the state. These patients are not Medicaid-eligible. Sometimes Medicaid state plans specify that Medicaid DSH payments are based upon a hospital's amount of charity care or general assistance days. This, however, is not “payment” for those days, and does not mean that the patient is eligible for Medicaid benefits or can be counted as such in the Medicare formula.
Other Excluded Days
Labor and Delivery Room Days
A day for which a Medicaid patient is in the labor and delivery area at census taking hour is excluded from Medicaid days unless the patient has occupied an inpatient routine bed at some time since admission. Hospitals that maintain a single multipurpose labor, delivery and postpartum (LDP) room may apportion both the days and available beds associated with LDP rooms between ancillary labor and delivery and the routine adults and pediatrics based upon the portion of the patient’s stay in the LDP room between ancillary and routine. For pro-ration purposes any time subsequent to the birth of the child is considered routine it may be burdensome for a hospital to determine on a per patient basis the amount of time spent in labor/delivery and the amount of time spent receiving routine care. A hospital may calculate an average percentage of time patients receive ancillary services, as opposed to routine inpatient care in the LDP room(s) during a typical month and apply that percentage through the rest of the year as identified in 68 Federal Register 45419. The days for Medicaid eligible patients in the LDP room apportioned to routine are added to both the numerator and the denominator of the Medicaid fraction. For compliance purposes, hospitals should ensure that all routine LDP days are included in the total day count, not solely Medicaid eligible days.
Unverifiable State Days
Represents days for patients that cannot be verified by state records to have fallen within a period wherein the patient was eligible for Medicaid.
Days in Excluded Units
This represents days in the psychiatric, skilled nursing or rehabilitation units of PPS hospitals. PPS Rehab units should submit separate listings and report the days separately on the Cost Report. Some state “paid claims” listings fail to separately identify the Title XIX excluded unit days but have the capability to do so. The hospital bears the burden of proof, therefore it’s the hospital responsibility to have the state identify the days and remove them from eligible Title XIX days.
Dual Entitlement Days
This represents patients that are entitled to both Medicare Part A and Medicaid on that day. 42 CFR 412.106(b)(4) precludes the counting of any patient days furnished to patients having both Medicare Part A and Medicaid. These dual-eligible patients are included in the Medicare fraction but not the Medicaid fraction as CMS indicated in 69 Fed. Reg. 49098. Additionally, patients who exhaust coverage for inpatient hospital services remain entitled to other Medicare Part A benefits, therefore these days are not included in the Medicaid fraction. Effective for discharges occurring on or after 10/1/2004, these days would be included by CMS in the Medicare fraction, whether or not the beneficiary has exhausted their Medicare Part A hospital coverage.
Qualifying for DSH Payments
The Statutory Formula
The most commonly used method for a hospital to qualify, is based on a complex statutory formula under which payment adjustments are based on the level of the hospital’s DSH patient percentage.
Under these formulas a hospital is classified as a “disproportionate share” hospital under any of the following circumstances. Starting with discharges occurring on or after 4/1/2001, the hospital’s disproportionate patient percentage is at least equal to one of the following:
- 15%, if the hospital is located in an urban area, and has 100 or more beds, or is located in a rural area and has 500 or more beds; or
- 15% if the hospital is located in a rural area and either has more than 100 beds and fewer than 500 beds or is classified as a sole community hospital under Section 412.92; or
- 15% if the hospital is located in an urban area and has fewer than 100 beds; or
- 15% if the hospital is located in a rural area and has 100 or fewer beds
Classification of Urban Versus Rural
As stated in 71 Fed. Reg. 48139 the hospital’s location, in an urban or rural area, is determined in accordance with the definitions in 42 CFR 412.64, except that a reclassification that results from an urban hospital reclassified as rural as set forth in 42 CFR 412.103 is classified as rural.
Posted 8/9/2024